The Role of the Whistleblower: A look at qui tam litigation
By Chuck Dukes
Qui tam litigation allows private citizens, like you, to join in the battle against government fraud. Every year, many of our public institutions—from the military to Medicare—are plagued by fraud. Astonishingly, it’s estimated that nearly 10% of all federal spending, or $350–$400B per year, is lost due to fraud.
And by and large, qui tam litigation has proven to be the most effective weapon there is to fight against government fraud. DOJ statistics show that from 1986–2017, more than 70% of the federal government’s total recovery for fraud has come through qui tam litigation, which led to over $40 billion being restored to the federal treasury.
QUI TAM LITIGATION UNDER THE FALSE CLAIMS ACT
Practically speaking, qui tam litigation is the procedure through which a private individual, commonly known as a “whistleblower,” files a lawsuit on behalf of the government to recover public funds. If the lawsuit is successful, the whistleblower is entitled to a share of the recovery.
Modern qui tam practice began in 1863 when Congress enacted the False Claims Act (“FCA”) in response to rampant fraud being committed against the government during the Civil War. The FCA prohibits anyone from knowingly committing fraud against the United States through the submission of false or fraudulent claims. Importantly, the FCA also includes qui tam provisions that allow private citizens to file suit on behalf of the United States to recover public funds. These whistleblowers, or “relators” as they are referred to under the statute, are individuals who have witnessed or have personal knowledge of fraud being committed against the government.
COMMON TYPES OF GOVERNMENT FRAUD
Today, most qui tam cases are filed against healthcare providers, financial institutions, or defense contractors for submitting false or fraudulent claims to the government for reimbursement. Qui tam cases involving healthcare fraud are the most common, and usually provide a majority of the government’s annual recovery under the FCA. These cases restore billions of dollars to our Medicare, Medicaid, and TRICARE programs every year, and save those programs billions more by deterring others from committing similar frauds.
Fraudulent billing schemes are most prevalent in the medical industry and typically involve doctors, hospitals, or laboratories that (1) bill for medical services that were never performed, (2) bill for services that were not medically necessary, or (3) upcode for medical services or equipment. These schemes are typically uncovered by doctors, nurses, accountants, administrators, or billing specialists who have first-hand knowledge of the fraud and may have been reprimanded, or even fired, for trying to expose it.
Lately, a surge of qui tam cases have also been filed for violations of the Stark Act and/or Anti-Kickback Statute, laws that generally prohibit doctors from receiving kickbacks for referring Medicare or Medicaid patients to other healthcare providers. These cases are typically filed by physicians who have rejected similar financial arrangements, nurses who become aware of the referral scheme, or by healthcare administrators with access to physician compensation matters who, during the course of their work, discover an illegal arrangement.
HOW WHISTLEBLOWERS ARE COMPENSATED
More often than not, qui tam cases involve hundreds or even thousands of false claims, so awards can be substantial. Defendants who are found liable for violations of the FCA face treble damages; civil penalties ranging from $10,957 to $21,916 per false claim; the government’s litigation costs; and the whistleblower’s expenses, attorneys’ fees, and costs.
For their efforts in exposing government fraud, whistleblowers are entitled to 10–30% of the government’s total recovery in the case. If the government has intervened, the whistleblower’s share is 15–25% of the total recovery. If the government has not intervened, that share can climb to 25–30%. In 2017, the average share was over a million dollars, with more than $390 million being awarded to whistleblowers collectively. Since 1986, whistleblowers have been awarded over $6 billion for their help in rooting out government fraud.
But invariably qui tam cases involve complex issues, are fiercely contested by deep-pocketed defendants, and require extensive discovery and costly expert testimony to prove. So if you have witnessed government fraud at work and are considering a qui tam case, be sure to contact a law firm like RPWB that has the knowledge, experience, and financial resources that qui tam litigation demands.
Our Experienced Lawyers
How can we help? Fill out the form for a free case review.
Contact Us
- Toll Free: 888.293.6883
Case Types
Mesothelioma
Worker rights / health
Criminal Defense
Consumer Protection
Drugs & Medical Devices
Personal Injury
Related Posts
Nov 15, 2024
Are Anxiety Treatments Covered Under Car Accidents?
Everyone thinks about the physical consequences of car accidents: fractures, concussions, scrapes, and bruises. However, fewer people consider the emotional and mental effects of collisions caused by the shock, noise, and sudden impact. Many of our car collision clients here at Rogers, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman LLC have come to us with anxiety issues that […]
READ MORENov 06, 2024
What Are My Legal Options if I Was Hit by a Drunk Driver?
When inebriated, drivers act recklessly on the road, react more slowly to potential danger, and make poor decisions for their own and others’ safety. Unfortunately, drunk driving laws do not deter every driver in Charleston, South Carolina. Our legal team at Rogers, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman LLC serves victims of drunk driving collisions all too […]
READ MORENov 01, 2024
Which Intersections in Charleston Are the Most Dangerous?
Charleston’s beauty and historical charm have attracted many new residents, but the city’s infrastructure hasn’t kept up with the growing population. The resulting congestion has led to a significant increase in accidents at several high-traffic intersections. Here are some of the most dangerous intersections in Charleston that you should be aware of: Dorchester Road and […]
READ MOREOct 03, 2024
Can Nerve Damage Occur After a Car Accident?
The aftermath of car accidents can introduce any number of stressors into your life: insurance negotiations, medical emergencies, property damage, and mental anxiety and trauma. While all these very real consequences come into play over time, victims notice their physical injuries immediately — and in some severe cases, those injuries last. Nerve damage sits near […]
READ MORESep 27, 2024
What Are the Most Dangerous Roads and Intersections in Mt. Pleasant?
Drivers are becoming increasingly frustrated when they get on the road in Mt. Pleasant. Local authorities simply have not kept up with their responsibility of providing a safe roadway for drivers. Furthermore, careless and reckless drivers have made the situation much worse. As a result, the area has a very high rate of serious car […]
READ MOREAug 15, 2024
Rogers, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman LLC Attorneys Named to 2025 The Best Lawyers in America®
Several Rogers, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman LLC attorneys have been selected to the 2025 The Best Lawyers in America list, with three receiving Lawyer of the Year awards. All are recognized for their accomplishments in numerous practice areas, including antitrust law, mass tort, personal injury, product liability, class action, and medical malpractice litigation. Rogers, Patrick, […]
READ MOREAug 09, 2024
Types of Car Accidents—Which Are the Most Common?
With so many distractions in vehicles, there are many ways to blunder the importance of giving the road your undivided attention. Considering there is a traffic collision on South Carolina’s roadways every 3.6 minutes, it is important to look at all the types of car accidents and possible ways to avoid them. Here is a […]
READ MOREJul 16, 2024
Quartz Countertops Silicosis Lawsuits: What You Should Know
If you are a worker in the countertop manufacturing industry, you have probably heard of the lung disease called “silicosis.” If you believe you have been affected by silica exposure while on the job, Rogers, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman LLC will help you. This article will provide an in-depth look at silicosis, its causes, and […]
READ MOREMay 17, 2024
Rogers, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman LLC Attorneys Named to 2024 South Carolina Super Lawyers and Rising Stars Lists
Rogers, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman LLC proudly announces that four of the firm’s attorneys have been named to the 2024 South Carolina Super Lawyers and Rising Stars lists. Charles W. Patrick, Jr., Esq. is a founding member of the firm and serves as of counsel. He is an esteemed personal injury and product liability lawyer […]
READ MOREApr 29, 2024
Gordon Rhea Nominated To Be US-VI Attorney General
RPWB would like to extend a congratulations to our colleague, Gordon Rhea, on his nomination to become the next Attorney General of the U.S. Virgin Islands. Governor Albert Bryan Jr. recently announced the nomination of Rhea, who worked at RPWB first as a member attorney and then later in an of counsel capacity. While at […]
READ MOREMar 22, 2024
Asbestos Finally Banned in United States
We’ve been waiting nearly 50 years to type this: Asbestos is finally banned in the United States. After decades of inadequate protections for workers, the EPA has finally banned the only remaining type of asbestos still imported into America. More than 50 countries have already banned the use of asbestos, which is known to cause […]
READ MOREJan 22, 2024
Gordon Rhea Wins USVI Bar Association’s Highest Honor
RPWB of counsel attorney Gordon Rhea was honored with the highest award during the Virgin Islands Bar Association’s annual meeting on December 8, 2023. The award ceremony highlighted Rhea’s dedication to the legal profession and his commitment, dedication and valuable contributions to the people of the Virgin Islands. The Winston A. Hodge Award for Public […]
READ MORENov 27, 2023
RPWB Represented a Whistleblower who Helped the Federal Government Recoup $1.7 million
ORLANDO, Fla. – The federal government has recouped $1.7 million from a healthcare provider who fraudulently billed Medicare and TRICARE for medical procedures that were not deemed necessary and were performed by an unqualified technician. In the settlement agreement, Jena Medical Group LLC, as well as several individuals associated with the company, have agreed to […]
READ MOREOct 17, 2023
Local Non-Profit to Receive $500,000 to Help Low Income Households Save Money on Power Bills
CHARLESTON, S.C. – A local energy conservation non-profit will receive nearly $500,000 to help low income residents in Berkeley, Georgetown and Horry counties conserve energy and save money on energy bills. The Sustainability Institute will receive $484,345.89 in unclaimed monies from the 2021 settlement of the class action lawsuit Hearn v. Santee Cooper. The case […]
READ MOREOct 02, 2023
RPWB Announces the Passing of J. David Butler
It is with great sorrow and heavy hearts that we announce the passing of our friend, colleague and law partner, J. David Butler on September 30, 2023, after a valiant three-year battle with cancer. He was a friend to all and was, quite simply, the nicest guy one could have the pleasure of knowing. Dave […]
READ MORE