$5.4 Million Settlement Reached in Fatal Charleston DUI

Chuck Dukes


CHARLESTON, S.C. — A case involving a 32-year-old Chicago man who was killed by a drunk driver in Charleston recently resolved for $5.4 million.

In January 2019, William Kappel, Jr. (deceased), his wife Laura, and Jacqueline Zink traveled to Charleston to visit their friend Joseph Murray, who had recently moved to the Lowcountry from Chicago. As they were heading home from an evening out in downtown Charleston, their vehicle was struck by a drunk driver.

Crash data revealed that the drunk driver, Cade Garris, reached speeds of 74 mph in a 35 mph zone moments before he ran a red light on Meeting Street and caused the fatal collision. Plaintiffs’ investigation revealed that Garris had been drinking at two establishments in downtown Charleston before he got behind the wheel to drive home. Later toxicology results also indicated that Garris was over twice the legal limit at the time of the collision.

Garris was underinsured and the bar defendants funded the bulk of the settlement. As a part of the settlement, one bar defendant will donate $25,000 to a foundation started in honor of Billy Kappel, implement annual safe-service alcohol training for its staff to help prevent similar tragedies in the future, and significantly lengthen its surveillance footage retention policy.

Under the terms of the parties’ settlement, other details, including the identities of the bar defendants and their attorneys, are unavailable.

Billy’s estate, Laura Kappel, and Jacqueline Zink were represented by Chuck Dukes of Rogers, Patrick Westbrook & Brickman, and Chris Moore and Terry Richardson of Richardson, Thomas, Haltiwanger, Moore & Lewis. Joseph Murray was represented by John Moylan and Lucy Dinkins of Wyche, P.A.

The settlement was finalized on Feb. 18th in front of U.S. District Court Judge David C. Norton.

Our Experienced Lawyers

How can we help? Fill out the form for a free case review.

    Contact Us

    Case Types

    Related Posts

    RPWB Welcomes a New Member

    Matt Nickles, who has worked as an associate at our firm since 2014, became a member at the beginning of this year.

    Nickles focuses on medical malpractice, nursing home neglect, catastrophic personal injury, premises liability, product liability, class actions and other complex litigation. He is experienced in litigating medical malpractice and pharmacy liability cases, including the case of a young girl with developmental disabilities who died as a result of being prescribed a fatal dose of phenobarbital.

    A native of Columbia, Nickles was exposed to the law at an early age. His mother worked as general counsel for the state Department of Social Services and his father is a well-known attorney who took on the video poker industry.

    It was those early experiences and the stories told around the dinner table that sparked an interest in the law. Nickles graduated with a degree in European history from Washington & Lee University and a law degree from the University of South Carolina School of Law.

    During law school, he interned for the Honorable Margaret Seymour, a federal judge in the District of South Carolina, and clerked for RPWB.

    Following graduation, he worked for a Columbia defense firm, Walker Reibold, before spending two years as a law clerk for the Honorable Richard Gergel.

    We are thrilled to have him as a part of our membership.

    Our Experienced Lawyers