The chase of PPP fraud is on
By Will Lewis
When the federal government raced to release more than $2.2 trillion in coronavirus aid earlier this year, it did so knowing that some of that money would go to fraudulent claims.
With the money needed immediately by struggling businesses and workers, the government could not efficiently control fraud on the front end, so it was willing to pay invalid claims knowing it will chase the money through aggressive civil and criminal enforcement actions, a practice called “pay and chase.”
While the federal government chasing fraud is nothing new, never has the chase involved so much money, paid out to so many, in such a short period of time. And complicating matters is that PPP recipients by their nature, are small businesses, not the highly-regulated industries used to receiving federal aid.
Government officials believe a significant portion of the $2.2 Trillion was obtained through fraud and are acting accordingly. We are starting to see the first Paycheck Protection Program prosecutions, and the Department of Justice is gearing up for enforcement actions. Attorney General Barr has directed every United States Attorney’s Office to focus on detecting, investigating, and prosecuting all criminal activity related to the COVID-19 pandemic. Here in South Carolina, U.S. Attorney Peter McCoy has created a multi-agency task force to root out PPP fraud.
Although impossible to predict the exact contours of the coming enforcement actions, we are beginning to see patterns in the charging decisions:
- There is a complex statutory and regulatory framework directly applicable to SBA Fraud. Knowingly submitting a false claim to the Small Business Administration, which administered PPP carries up to 2 years in prison and a $5,000 fine. Prosecutors also can charge for making a false statement to the government or to a financial institution, which carry up to 5 years and 30 years respectively.
- The government can go after cases in which no money actually changed hands. Even conspiracy to defraud charges carry the risk of significant prison time. The primary driver for sentencing in these PPP fraud cases, absent extreme circumstances, will be the amount of money applied for in the fraudulent loans.
- Criminal liability will be around for a long time. Due to the fact that PPP fraud will almost always involve a financial institution, federal prosecutors can charge crimes with 10-year statutes of limitation. This means PPP criminal liability will be out there until 2030.
People or businesses that find themselves a subject or target of a PPP or Cares Act fraud investigation should immediately retain a criminal defense attorney who focuses on white-collar crimes. Not only should the attorney be well-versed with the complex legal framework for PPP fraud cases, but it will also help if the attorney understands how the government intends to enforce it.
William C. Lewis (“Will”), a former Assistant United States Attorney for the District of South Carolina, prosecuted healthcare fraud, public corruption, human trafficking and violent offenses at both the trial and appellate levels. He now practices with the firm of Richardson, Patrick, Westbrook and Brickman, where he focuses on False Claims Act Whistleblower (“Qui Tam”) actions, Class Actions, and White-Collar Criminal Defense. He can be reached at 803-259-3527 or by email at firstname.lastname@example.org
Our Experienced Lawyers
How can we help? Fill out the form for a free case review.
- Toll Free: 888.293.6883
Sep 09, 2020
The chase of PPP fraud is on
By Will Lewis When the federal government raced to release more than $2.2 trillion in coronavirus aid earlier this year, it did so knowing that some of that money would go to fraudulent claims. With the money needed immediately by struggling businesses and workers, the government could not efficiently control fraud on the front end, […]READ MORE
Aug 25, 2020
Top-Listed Firm for Personal Injury, Product Liability and Mass Torts
RPWB is the top-listed plaintiff law firm in South Carolina for personal injury, product liability and mass tort litigation in the 2021 edition of The Best Lawyers in America®. In all, 19 RPWB attorneys were named Best Lawyers in their respective practice areas. Two other RPWB lawyers were named “Ones to Watch,” a designation for […]READ MORE
Mar 02, 2020
How are Mesothelioma Lawsuits Paid Out?
By Ken Wilson Some of the most frequent questions we get about mesothelioma lawsuits concern how they are ultimately paid out to clients and how long it will all take. To address those questions, let me give you a little bit of context about how mesothelioma lawsuits work. When a person is diagnosed with mesothelioma, […]READ MORE
Feb 21, 2020
Terry Richardson Honored with the 2020 War Horse Award
NEW ORLEANS, Louisiana — RPWB founding attorney Terry Richardson was honored with the War Horse Award by the Southern Trial Lawyers Association this week, a distinction recognizing his contributions to the legal profession over the past 40 years. From the nameplate on his desk (“Illegitimis non carborundum” – Don’t let the bastards wear you down) […]READ MORE
Feb 02, 2020
$1.5 Billion Syngenta Corn Farmer Settlement Finalized
Corn Farmer Settlement Checks Are On The Way This week we received some very good news for corn farmers nationwide who suffered price losses associated with the botched launch of genetically-modified corn seed by Syngenta in 2013. On January 3, 2020, the U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas in Kansas City approved a […]READ MORE
Feb 01, 2020
RPWB is a 2020 U.S. News & World Report Best Law Firm
CHARLESTON, S.C. – U.S. News & World Report has named Richardson, Patrick, Westbrook & Brickman as a 2020 Best Law Firm for the firm’s work in personal injury, mass torts and class actions, product liability, medical malpractice, securities litigation, healthcare law and railroad law. U.S. News’ announcement came on the heels of the 2020 Best […]READ MORE
Jan 31, 2020
16 RPWB Lawyers Selected For Best Lawyers List
CHARLESTON – RPWB was once again the top-listed plaintiff law firm in South Carolina for product liability cases as well as mass tort and class action lawsuits in the 2020 edition of The Best Lawyers in America®, which was released in August 2019. In total, 16 RPWB attorneys were designated as 2020 Best Lawyers, including […]READ MORE
Jan 30, 2020
Asbestos causes mesothelioma, and now scientists know why
It is no secret that exposure to asbestos causes cancer. However, while scientists definitively established this link decades ago, the exact mechanism was still a mystery. A recent study apparently demonstrates just how asbestos causes mesothelioma, which at some point in the future could possibly be helpful to doctors in South Carolina who treat patients […]READ MORE
Jan 22, 2020
Study confirms link between cosmetic products and mesothelioma
Wearing makeup and using other cosmetic products is quite common in South Carolina. Unfortunately, just because something is common does not mean it is safe. For example, asbestos contamination is shockingly common in the cosmetics industry. A recent study established a definite link between the deadly cancer mesothelioma and asbestos found in many cosmetic products. […]READ MORE
Jan 18, 2020
FDA pushes for more testing amid asbestos exposure concern
Current asbestos testing standards for industries that use talc are fairly loose. As recent reports have shown that many products contain this toxic substance, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration is pushing for new testing standards. If implemented, it could possibly lower the risk of asbestos exposure for people in South Carolina and across the […]READ MORE
Jan 17, 2020
Is diagnosing mesothelioma difficult?
If you’ve worked in a job that exposed you to asbestos, you may already know the risk for mesothelioma. But when the disease takes years to show up, how do doctors know whether or not you have it? Mesothelioma is a rare disease. And many different illnesses have similar symptoms. To diagnose patients, doctors must […]READ MORE
Jan 15, 2020
How can I find clinical trials for mesothelioma?
If you have mesothelioma from asbestos exposure, you know that only limited treatment exists. However, science is always searching for new ways to treat or cure the disease. If you have exhausted your options for treatment, a clinical trial can test out a new way to fight your mesothelioma. Your doctor may be aware of […]READ MORE
Jan 08, 2020
Asbestos litigation: Johnson & Johnson faces another lawsuit
South Carolina consumers should feel confident that they are making safe purchases, but this is unfortunately more difficult than it seems. Companies are frequently more concerned with their own bottom lines than they are with the health and safety of their customers. Concerned over citizens’ safety, one state is engaging in asbestos litigation against Valeant […]READ MORE
Dec 31, 2019
Construction workers learn of asbestos exposure months later
There is a very good reason that asbestos abatement is tightly regulated in South Carolina. When mishandled, asbestos fibers are released into the air. Those airborne fibers are easily inhaled. For those who do not quite understand just how serious this is, it is important to know that asbestos exposure can lead to a number […]READ MORE
Dec 23, 2019
Miners, construction workers at higher risk for mesothelioma
Asbestos has not disappeared from South Carolina. Whether from old buildings and products or in new uses, asbestos can still be found in many — all over and even in the workplace. Almost anyone could be at risk for exposure, but there are some who face an even greater risk than others. Here are some […]READ MORE